Links
Archives
Thursday, January 12, 2006
First, here's Andrew Sullivan's take... ...on the James Frey/Larry King interview last night that UD live blogged: About the best television I've seen in forever. This will do as a camp-loving description of events, and certainly UD remembers tolerating tv for years on the basis of this campy spectatorship: the so-bad-it's-good thing, the let's see how weird this can get thing... As her readers know, however, this approach eventually failed UD and she stopped watching. But she'd like to offer, for what it's worth, a truth-loving description of events. "There are two sorts of people in the world," she said to her husband as she returned to her house last night. "Those who love the truth and those who do not." Okay. Not earth-shattering, but, again, I said for what it's worth. I mean, take Albert Camus. He loved the clarified landscapes of North Africa because they showed him, beautifully, what was true in life. We live with a few familiar ideas. Two or three. We polish and transform them according to the societies and the men we happen to meet. ...And, I don't know why, but faced with this ravined landscape, this solemn and lugubrious cry of stone, Djemila, inhuman at nightfall, faced with this death of colors and hope, I was certain that when they reach the end of their lives, men worthy of the name must rediscover this confrontation, deny the few ideas they had, and recover the innocence and truth that gleamed in the eyes of the Ancients face to face with destiny... I feel certain that the true, the only, progress of civilization, the one to which a man devotes himself from time to time, lies in creating conscious deaths. The reason UD finds what people like Frey did so despicable is that in convincing people they are truth-lovers, in flaunting a truth-bearing "death of colors and hope" in their narrated physical and spiritual disintegration, they tell the worst lie of all. They corrupt our relationship to the truth by pretending successfully to be the truth, when in fact they represent sensationalistic and comforting lies. That's why it's sickening for UD when Deus ex Operahs descend and soothingly assure their desperate audience that as long as their books keep telling redemptive lies they must keep reading and believing them. |