Teach for America’s staffers have discovered that past performance — especially the kind you can measure — is the best predictor of future performance [as a teacher]. Recruits who have achieved big, measurable goals in college tend to do so as teachers. And the two best metrics of previous success tend to be grade-point average and “leadership achievement” — a record of running something and showing tangible results. If you not only led a tutoring program but doubled its size, that’s promising.
Knowledge matters, but not in every case. In studies of high-school math teachers, majoring in the subject seems to predict better results in the classroom. And more generally, people who attended a selective college are more likely to excel as teachers (although graduating from an Ivy League school does not unto itself predict significant gains in a Teach for America classroom). Meanwhile, a master’s degree in education seems to have no impact on classroom effectiveness.
Trackback URL for this post:
https://www.margaretsoltan.com/wp-trackback.php?p=20974
7 Responses to “From “What Makes A Great Teacher?” in the latest…”
Comment on this Entry
Latest UD posts at IHE
Archives
- 2021 (134)
- 2020 (790)
- 2019 (754)
- 2018 (803)
- 2017 (749)
- 2016 (863)
- 2015 (861)
- 2014 (1052)
- 2013 (1019)
- 2012 (1187)
- 2011 (1399)
- 2010 (1372)
- 2009 (1450)
- 2007 (1)
Categories
- 54: The new elderly (1)
- amy bishop (31)
- AYE (4)
- bad writing (23)
- Balinesia (1)
- be still my heart (161)
- beware the b-school boys (140)
- beach blogging (4)
- blog (97)
- blogoscopy (31)
- blood blogging (3)
- chief inspiration officer (28)
- class (11)
- CLICK-THROUGH U. (5)
- CLICK-THRU U. (124)
- code brown (13)
- conflict of interest (303)
- contest! (8)
- da guy's got balls (5)
- defenses of liberal education (28)
- delillo (55)
- democracy (741)
- demon rum (57)
- diploma mill (113)
- dispatches from the classroom (12)
- end the erasure of women (33)
- evil dr phil (1)
- EVITA (6)
- extracts (128)
- faculty project (34)
- failure to yield pun (3)
- father/son gunnies (9)
- FGM (45)
- floridly overwritten (3)
- foreign universities (159)
- forms of religious experience (400)
- free speech (60)
- fresh blood (12)
- Genius of the Carpathians (144)
- ghost writing (54)
- goathean (2)
- goddess (2)
- Gomer (6)
- good writing (87)
- great writing (130)
- guns (314)
- harvard: bar fly (4)
- harvard: foreign and domestic policy (87)
- harvard: gearing up for the winter (5)
- harvard: handouts (8)
- headline of the day (304)
- henry purcell (12)
- heroes (84)
- heroines (64)
- high as a kite (37)
- hoax (207)
- how to make ud happy (16)
- How We Learn (28)
- hymnal (1)
- intellectuals (61)
- it's art (86)
- it's good to be the king (9)
- james joyce (69)
- jesus thinks you're a jerk (2)
- just plain gross (247)
- kind of a little weird (324)
- limericks (128)
- lion's willy (1)
- little hitler (2)
- Little Ick (12)
- march of science (199)
- merchandise (163)
- merkin muffley (2)
- merkins (12)
- Ministry of War (9)
- misconceived literary adaptations (1)
- newspaper poem (13)
- notes from a broad (1)
- Nuts 'n Thugs Middle School (1)
- oedipus madoff (9)
- Of Mice and Men (1)
- Online Makeover (14)
- pill mill u. (7)
- plagiarism (281)
- poem (377)
- PowerPoint Confidential (15)
- powerpoint pissoff (50)
- professors (624)
- program support coordinator (2)
- protect yourself from bad poetry (2)
- satanic two-party system (1)
- Scathing Online Schoolmarm (247)
- screwed (130)
- screwed up (6)
- sentences that make UD laugh (11)
- smackdown (9)
- snapshots from a country (1)
- snapshots from assateague (10)
- snapshots from cambridge (6)
- snapshots from cherry springs (1)
- snapshots from corning (2)
- snapshots from dublin (21)
- snapshots from galway (8)
- snapshots from hawaii (1)
- snapshots from home (1,097)
- snapshots from hungary (2)
- snapshots from hyde park (2)
- snapshots from iceland (1)
- snapshots from ireland (12)
- snapshots from key west (66)
- snapshots from kurdistan (1)
- snapshots from la (1)
- snapshots from london (4)
- snapshots from malaga (1)
- snapshots from marbella (1)
- snapshots from munich (1)
- snapshots from new york (5)
- snapshots from Paris (3)
- snapshots from prague (2)
- snapshots from rehoboth (129)
- snapshots from sanibel (10)
- snapshots from sedona (14)
- snapshots from shenandoah (9)
- snapshots from summit (28)
- snapshots from the alps (1)
- snapshots from the caliphate (1)
- snapshots from the Chesapeake (1)
- snapshots from utah (7)
- snapshots from vermont (2)
- snapshots from Virginia (1)
- snapshots from warsaw (12)
- snapshots from west virginia (2)
- soltan inc. (52)
- somewhat baffled online schoolmarm (2)
- sounds and looks very samuel beckett (16)
- Sport (124)
- sport (2,661)
- STUDENTS (410)
- suicide (2)
- swaddled masses yearning to breathe free (5)
- tax syphon u. (1)
- tea (26)
- TEACH NAKED (2)
- TEACHING BEAUTY (2)
- technolust (216)
- THAT WHICH DOES NOT KILL ME (3)
- the melnyk chronicles (1)
- the most irresponsible university in america (5)
- the piece that passeth all understanding (4)
- the rest is silence (35)
- the university (411)
- This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (2)
- tiny (2)
- trust me – i'm a doctor (7)
- trustees trashing the place (218)
- ud officially embarrassed to be a woman (4)
- ud's hippie years (11)
- UD/DC (6)
- VERY LIKE A CME. (4)
- We'll get through this. (46)
- what do english professors dream? (1)
- where the simulacrum ends (31)
- you're wrong (1)
- Your Morning Giggle (41)
January 30th, 2010 at 7:04PM
A master of education degree has no impact in the classroom? I’m shocked, SHOCKED!
January 30th, 2010 at 7:50PM
Actually, Thomas, I was surprised to see that a masters in education didn’t LOWER classroom effectiveness.
January 30th, 2010 at 11:41PM
Another interesting (but not surprising) point from the article:
“They were also perpetually looking for ways to improve their effectiveness. For example, when Farr called up teachers who were making remarkable gains and asked to visit their classrooms, he noticed he’d get a similar response from all of them: “They’d say, ‘You’re welcome to come, but I have to warn you—I am in the middle of just blowing up my classroom structure and changing my reading workshop because I think it’s not working as well as it could.’ When you hear that over and over, and you don’t hear that from other teachers, you start to form a hypothesis.” Great teachers, he concluded, constantly reevaluate what they are doing.”
January 31st, 2010 at 8:04AM
Great Teachers are great tinkerers…
One of the best I’ve known used to destroy his notes every year and write new ones.
The other kept a detailed diary about how each of his classes went. What worked and what didn’t – so that the next year he would do a better job. This guy was also the author of a widely used chemistry textbook.
Such activities give those of us who are not “naturals” hope. There really is not excuse for not doing at least a decent job teaching.
(Ducks..)
January 31st, 2010 at 11:21AM
hmmm. So somebody with a high GPA and a record of excellence in something besides school work turns out to be a great teacher. Aren’t these the same students who excel in Law School/Medical School and make great lawyers and doctors? Who knew?
(sarcasm/) If only there was some way we could attract excellent students with strong leadership skills to the teaching profession. I wonder what kind of incentives they might need? (\sarcasm)
January 31st, 2010 at 11:37AM
Aren’t these the same students…?
No
Incentives?
Most of the good teachers I know in K-12 do it because they want to make a difference.
And no, I am not being sarcastic.
January 31st, 2010 at 11:49AM
“I wonder what kind of incentives they might need? (\sarcasm)”
One of the things that high-quality people look for in employment choices is a reasonable degree of autonomy and the ability to stand or fall based on their own performance. It is hard to imaging anything more contrary to these attributes than the highly-bureaucratized and lock-step environment that exists in the typical public school system.