← Previous Post: | Next Post:


A severely unbalanced individual.

Sam Thomas, a history professor at UAH, where Amy Bishop taught (he, like a number of people on that campus, knew her to be violently unstable before she began shooting), corrects one of the several destructive misintepretations of this event:

…[B]y linking Amy Bishop’s insanity to workplace frustration, [people] are implicitly pathologizing all women. If the shooting were simply an extreme reaction to a common frustration (as opposed to the most deadly spasm of violence from a severely unbalanced individual), the logical conclusion is that all women are capable of (or even prone to) this kind of violence. Given that, why in God’s name would I ever hire so unbalanced a creature as a woman?

Margaret Soltan, February 25, 2010 3:06PM
Posted in: amy bishop

Trackback URL for this post:

2 Responses to “A severely unbalanced individual.”

  1. Stephen Karlson Says:

    Let’s keep that logical corrective in mind the next time a pundit makes a generalization about male propensities to violence.

  2. MattF Says:

    I guess the non-sexist version is “Why would I ever hire a human, given their violent propensities.” And if your reaction is “Hmmm…”, you’ve missed the point.

Comment on this Entry

Latest UD posts at IHE