← Previous Post: | Next Post:

 

‘Reasonable people can and will disagree as to the merit of the charges filed by the Manhattan DA’s office, to the rightness of Penny’s intervention, and to his acquittal. Confined in the car with Neely and a bunch of frightened and vulnerable people, Penny can hardly be said to have gone in search of a proving ground that day. The question of whether he misapplied the choke that must have seemed like the least of all bad options was rightly a main focus of the trial.’

What shouldn’t be in dispute, however, is that the status quo regarding crime, mental health, and homelessness is intolerable… [P]eople suffering from severe mental illness are, in fact, more likely to commit violent crimes

**************************

Bring back involuntary commitment.

I understand that some varieties of this exist in some states. But look around. They are too lax, too complicated.

***************************

When I look at Goya’s picture of institutional life in 18th century Spain, I see human beings haunted by terrifying delusions, left to waste away in the dark, the dank, and the cold—but this resembles nothing so much as the current state of affairs in our subways, underpasses, and public parks. Contrary to the medical reality of Goya’s day, or the imagined setting of Cuckoo’s Nest, we do have the power to beat back severe mental illness in a patient’s brain, in an environment that is safe, clean, and calm. Not every patient will get better, but many will, and every single one deserves that chance. The bottom line is that inside of treatment, some of these people will get better. Outside of it, almost none will.

Margaret Soltan, December 15, 2024 11:24AM
Posted in: headline of the day

Trackback URL for this post:
https://www.margaretsoltan.com/wp-trackback.php?p=78138

Comment on this Entry

Latest UD posts at IHE

Archives

Categories