← Previous Post: | Next Post:

 

What Happens When Your Discipline is a Mess.

A researcher who has written a book about the grant and fellowship review process describes how various disciplines fared on the panels she observed. Here’s English.

… Panelists who are in English literature perceive that their discipline has a “legitimization crisis.” Perhaps because of the influence of poststructuralism in the discipline, literary scholars are particularly aware that the standards of evaluation are intersubjective, resulting from the interaction of panelists. They’re ambivalent about how successful a peer-review panel can be. Asked whether “the cream rises to the top,” they emphasize that doesn’t necessarily happen. Some are unsure whether “quality” exists.

Even if you didn’t have such relativistic views of excellence, the question of how to evaluate literary studies remains open. At one point, there was agreement on mastery of close reading, how language works. But three trends have undermined that consensus: critique of canonization and of privileging the written text; a widening of interest to include history, anthropology and the social context in which a text is written; and challenges — whether from Marxism, psychoanalysis, poststructuralism — to the whole idea of “representation.”

One result is that literature proposals don’t do as well in multidisciplinary panels. One panelist told me, “At some point, somebody said, ‘Gosh, we’re giving all the awards to historians.’ And I remember thinking, ‘That’s not surprising.’…

Margaret Soltan, April 3, 2009 2:22PM
Posted in: intellectuals

Trackback URL for this post:
https://www.margaretsoltan.com/wp-trackback.php?p=11194

3 Responses to “What Happens When Your Discipline is a Mess.”

  1. Shannon Chamberlain Says:

    I’m holding out (probably too much) hope for the new trend in criticism called new ethics, which attempts to tackle the question of what literature–the novel in particular–does to our ability to perceive the world and the different ways people think about it. It started, maybe, in postcolonial studies, but I think people are realizing that it has implications outside some hazy idea of an ethnic Other. About half of my first year cohort at Berkeley seems interested in the new ethics (I’m reading Martha Nussbaum right now), which differs from a lot of this structuralist-poststructuralist nonsense in that it posits a world outside the text that can and should be represented. It’s not in the least bit relativistic, which is comforting. I have some reservations about subordinating a more aesthetic approach to philosophy because I’m suspicious about interdisciplinarity in general, but I’m willing to think positively about this development.

  2. Crimson05er Says:

    " One panelist told me, “At some point, somebody said, ‘Gosh, we’re giving all the awards to historians.’ And I remember thinking, ‘That’s not surprising.’… "

    Well, at least one good piece of news for the historians out there.

    As someone on the border between American History and Lit, I sometimes feel like I’m squeezed within two fields collapsing in on one another.

  3. Margaret Soltan Says:

    Crimson05er: Funny!

Comment on this Entry

UD REVIEWED

Dr. Bernard Carroll, known as the "conscience of psychiatry," contributed to various blogs, including Margaret Soltan's University Diaries, for which he sometimes wrote limericks under the name Adam.
New York Times

George Washington University English professor Margaret Soltan writes a blog called University Diaries, in which she decries the Twilight Zone-ish state our holy land’s institutes of higher ed find themselves in these days.
The Electron Pencil

It’s [UD's] intellectual honesty that makes her blog required reading.
Professor Mondo

There's always something delightful and thought intriguing to be found at Margaret Soltan's no-holds-barred, firebrand tinged blog about university life.
AcademicPub

You can get your RDA of academic liars, cheats, and greedy frauds at University Diaries. All disciplines, plus athletics.
truffula, commenting at Historiann

Margaret Soltan at University Diaries blogs superbly and tirelessly about [university sports] corruption.
Dagblog

University Diaries. Hosted by Margaret Soltan, professor of English at George Washington University. Boy is she pissed — mostly about athletics and funding, the usual scandals — but also about distance learning and diploma mills. She likes poems too. And she sings.
Dissent: The Blog

[UD belittles] Mrs. Palin's degree in communications from the University of Idaho...
The Wall Street Journal

Professor Margaret Soltan, blogging at University Diaries... provide[s] an important voice that challenges the status quo.
Lee Skallerup Bessette, Inside Higher Education

[University Diaries offers] the kind of attention to detail in the use of language that makes reading worthwhile.
Sean Dorrance Kelly, Harvard University

Margaret Soltan's ire is a national treasure.
Roland Greene, Stanford University

The irrepressibly to-the-point Margaret Soltan...
Carlat Psychiatry Blog

Margaret Soltan, whose blog lords it over the rest of ours like a benevolent tyrant...
Perplexed with Narrow Passages

Margaret Soltan is no fan of college sports and her diatribes on the subject can be condescending and annoying. But she makes a good point here...
Outside the Beltway

From Margaret Soltan's excellent coverage of the Bernard Madoff scandal comes this tip...
Money Law

University Diaries offers a long-running, focused, and extremely effective critique of the university as we know it.
Anthony Grafton, American Historical Association

The inimitable Margaret Soltan is, as usual, worth reading. ...
Medical Humanities Blog

I awake this morning to find that the excellent Margaret Soltan has linked here and thereby singlehandedly given [this blog] its heaviest traffic...
Ducks and Drakes

As Margaret Soltan, one of the best academic bloggers, points out, pressure is mounting ...
The Bitch Girls

Many of us bloggers worry that we don’t post enough to keep people’s interest: Margaret Soltan posts every day, and I more or less thought she was the gold standard.
Tenured Radical

University Diaries by Margaret Soltan is one of the best windows onto US university life that I know.
Mary Beard, A Don's Life

[University Diaries offers] a broad sense of what's going on in education today, framed by a passionate and knowledgeable reporter.
More magazine, Canada

If deity were an elected office, I would quit my job to get her on the ballot.
Notes of a Neophyte

Archives

Categories