Yale Daily News:
… SMART Boards, which connect to regular computers and allow users to edit documents on the larger screen with stylus-type markers, came to Yale about four years ago as a high-tech alternative to chalkboards. There are currently about a dozen of the machines, which cost about $12,000 each, scattered in classrooms across Central Campus.
… Pedro Monroy, who oversees classroom media services at Yale, [said] that he does not get many requests from professors asking that SMART Boards be added to their classrooms across campus.
That’s an unfortunate commentary for a technology in which Yale has invested hundreds of thousands of dollars.
… [T]echnology is often a tough sell at Yale; [the university] stopped holding general lessons for faculty across the University before SMART Boards even came to campus because of lack of interest…
… Anne Fadiman, Yale’s Francis writer-in-residence and adjunct English professor, [is] content to teach with just chalk and a blackboard and a dozen students gathered around a table.
Asked why she doesn’t use a SMART Board, Fadiman replied in an e-mail message, “They’re too smart for me.”
****************
Who sent this Onion report on classroom technology use to UD? She can’t remember. Anyway.
September 8th, 2009 at 3:00AM
When I was in high school, whenever a teacher spent class time fixing or fiddling with the audiovisual equipment, it was customary for a handful of students to imitate the high-pitched beep of the Emergency Broadcast System test pattern, quietly, from the back of the classroom.
September 8th, 2009 at 6:53AM
$12,000 each. Wow. I had no idea that SMART Boards were so expensive.
There are a few in the library of the university where UD and I teach, although I’ve only seen them used, without using one myself. Like PowerPoint, these boards *can* be useful if used, well, smartly–to display a particular website, or ways of navigating a book/article search through several screens, or other specific activities better demonstrated than described.
That said, I’m with Anne Fadiman: Give me a chalkboard, and give me chalk on my hands after I teach.
September 8th, 2009 at 7:24AM
I sent you the Onion link UD.
Wonder how much those touch screen thingies they use on CNN are. I would bite somebody to have one of those things in my lecture room. Next up: Powerpoint in 3D!
September 8th, 2009 at 7:42AM
Thanks, Shane.
September 8th, 2009 at 12:58PM
I know several faculty who insist on Smartboards for their classes; the boards record what they write, so a record of the lecture can be posted on the course website after class. It’s way more useful if you’re teaching something boardwork-intensive like math. (Honestly, I don’t think it’s that good for showing pictures. That’s what PowerPoint is *for*, really.)
September 8th, 2009 at 3:19PM
Michael Schrage on "sparkly tools."
September 9th, 2009 at 6:41AM
In HS it was mostly science/math teachers that wanted these. In college, professors don’t even know how to turn on a DVD player.
September 9th, 2009 at 7:02AM
lelangir: And University Diaries aims to keep it that way…